← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete Regulations Respecting Zoning at Toronto/Buttonville Airport SOR/88-148 · 2006
Summary

Zoning regulations for Toronto/Buttonville Airport establishing height restrictions, approach surfaces, and land use limitations to ensure aviation safety around the airport

Reason

These regulations violate property rights, suppress land development, and artificially constrain housing supply in the Greater Toronto Area. The safety benefits could be achieved through voluntary easements, liability insurance, and market pricing of risk. The hidden costs include reduced economic productivity, higher housing costs, and lost tax revenue. Government zoning creates a rigid, knowledge-insensitive framework that prevents landowners from optimizing their property use.

keep Regulations Respecting Zoning at Cranbrook Airport SOR/88-126 · 2006
Summary

These regulations establish height restrictions and land use controls around Cranbrook Airport to protect aviation safety. They define imaginary surfaces (approach, outer, transitional) and prohibit any structures or objects from encroaching on these surfaces. The Minister can require removal of excessive natural growth, and waste disposal that attracts birds is prohibited to prevent bird strikes.

Reason

Aviation safety has severe externalities—a single bird strike or obstacle collision can cause mass casualties and catastrophic economic damage. While the regulation restricts property rights, the narrowly defined geographic zones and precise height limits are technically necessary to prevent accidents that would harm both airport users and surrounding communities. These protections would be extremely difficult to replicate through voluntary means or market mechanisms due to the impossibility of pricing the risk of rare but catastrophic events and the tragedy of the commons in navigable airspace.

keep Regulations Respecting Zoning at Pembroke Airport SOR/88-125 · 2006
Summary

This regulation establishes zoning restrictions around Pembroke Airport to protect airspace from obstructions. It prohibits construction or natural growth exceeding defined approach, outer, and transitional surfaces, and bans waste disposal that could attract birds, aiming to ensure safe aircraft operations.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off due to significantly increased risk of fatal aircraft crashes if obstructions were allowed. This regulation achieves safety through uniform, enforceable standards covering all affected lands—a coordination solution private transactions cannot reliably match, especially with changing ownership and the need for comprehensive, contiguous airspace protection.

delete Regulations Respecting Zoning at Churchill Airport SOR/88-124 · 2006
Summary

The Churchill Airport Zoning Regulations restrict building heights, natural growth, and waste disposal on lands near Churchill Airport to protect aircraft operations. They define imaginary approach/transitional/outer surfaces and prohibit any structure or object exceeding those surfaces.

Reason

Keeping this regulation imposes ongoing costs on landowners by restricting property rights without compensation, reducing land values and development potential. It creates precedent for further zoning restrictions that distort markets, reduce supply of developable land, and contribute to housing unaffordability. The same safety objectives could be achieved more efficiently through market mechanisms such as the airport purchasing easements or liability rules, avoiding the deadweight loss and property rights violations inherent in command-and-control zoning.

delete Order Prescribing the Fees and Charges To Be Paid for the Provision of Satellite Remote Sensing Imagery, Tapes, and Services SOR/87-96 · 2006
Summary

A fee schedule for satellite remote sensing services provided by the Minister of Energy, Mines and Resources, with volume discounts for heavy users.

Reason

This is a straightforward fee recovery mechanism that should be privatized. The government has no business selling satellite imagery - this is a commercial activity that private providers can handle. Keeping it creates unnecessary government involvement in a market that functions well without state intervention, potentially crowding out private satellite operators and distorting the market. The revenue from this order likely doesn't justify the administrative burden or the competitive disadvantage to private sector providers.

delete Regulations Respecting Insurance of Loans Made to Versatile Pacific Shipyards Inc. SOR/87-95 · 2006
Summary

Government insurance program for loans to Versatile Pacific Shipyards Inc. to complete icebreaker construction, covering up to $13 million with 0.5% annual fee

Reason

This regulation represents corporate welfare that distorts market incentives, exposes taxpayers to risk, and creates moral hazard by guaranteeing loans for a specific company's operations rather than letting market forces determine viable shipbuilding projects

keep Regulations Respecting Zoning at Saskatoon Airport SOR/87-706 · 2006
Summary

Zoning regulations establishing height restrictions, approach surfaces, and land use limitations around Saskatoon Airport to ensure aviation safety and prevent bird attractants near the airport.

Reason

Aviation safety requires predictable airspace management. Without these regulations, buildings or structures could obstruct flight paths, creating collision risks. The bird attractant prohibition prevents wildlife hazards. These technical safety standards would be difficult to coordinate without centralized regulation.

keep Regulations Respecting Zoning at Prince Albert Airport SOR/87-705 · 2006
Summary

Airport zoning regulations for Prince Albert Airport that establish imaginary airspace surfaces (approach, outer, and transitional) to prevent obstructions and prohibit waste disposal that could attract birds. Restrictions apply to lands within defined boundaries, limiting building heights to ensure aviation safety.

Reason

Deletion would create unacceptable aviation safety risks, including potential aircraft collisions with obstacles and increased bird strikes. These clear and present dangers to human life cannot be adequately addressed through ex post facto tort liability, making preventative zoning a necessary and proportionate exercise of government's legitimate role in protecting public safety.

delete Order Providing for the Fixing and Imposing of Levies on Pulse Crops Produced in Saskatchewan and Marketed in Interprovincial and Export Trade SOR/87-701 · 2006
Summary

Imposes a 1% levy on gross value of pulse crops traded interprovincially/exported from Saskatchewan, deducted by buyers/assemblers/processors from producer payments and remitted monthly to a Board with producer details; research institution crops exempt.

Reason

Compulsory wealth transfer from producers to a marketing board with no voluntary opt-out, enforced through buyer reporting burdens; perpetuates interprovincial trade barriers contrary to national unity and economic efficiency; funds administrative overhead likely used to distort markets rather than let price signals coordinate supply; reduces producer revenue and creates red tape without addressing any genuine market failure that voluntary associations couldn't handle.

keep Zoning Regulations Respecting Wabush Airport SOR/87-7 · 2006
Summary

Establishes height restrictions and land use controls around Wabush Airport in Newfoundland to prevent obstructions in aircraft approach paths and reduce bird strike hazards. Defines imaginary surfaces (approach, outer, transitional) that buildings/structures cannot exceed, gives Minister power to order removal of encroaching natural growth, and prohibits waste disposal that attracts birds.

Reason

Aviation safety is a legitimate government role protecting lives and property from clear physical dangers. While the regulation restricts property rights, the spillover harm from aircraft accidents justifies preventative rules. The narrow, technical approach is reasonably tailored to the specific hazard and could not be easily replicated by tort law alone (which is reactive, not preventative). The alternative—waiting for crashes to establish liability—is insufficient for such catastrophic risks. However, a market-based system of tradable development rights or compensation to landowners would be more economically efficient.

delete Regulations Respecting Special Excise Services SOR/87-689 · 2006
Summary

Regulates special excise services performed by officers outside normal hours or at non-standard locations, establishing fee structures and cost recovery for government services related to alcohol, tobacco, and other excise-controlled goods.

Reason

Creates unnecessary government bureaucracy and cost recovery mechanisms that distort market pricing, discourage legitimate business operations, and impose compliance costs that ultimately reduce economic efficiency without providing proportional public benefit.

delete Order Respecting the Fixing and Imposing of Levies on, and the Collecting of Levies From, Producers of Wood in the Labelle Area in the Province of Quebec, With Respect to the Marketing of Wood in Interprovincial and Export Trade SOR/87-663 · 2006
Summary

Imposes a mandatory levy on wood producers in Labelle County, Quebec for all wood sold in interprovincial or export markets, with rates varying by measurement unit. The levy must be paid to the Wood Producers' Syndicate, either by producers directly or via deduction by marketers.

Reason

This is a protectionist trade barrier that imposes direct costs on interprovincial commerce, benefiting a private syndicate at the expense of Canadian economic integration. It contradicts Canada's need to eliminate internal trade barriers, increases costs for producers and consumers, and creates perverse incentives to avoid cross-province trade. The levy exists not for public benefit but to fund a producer group, representing rent-seeking that undermines competition and national market efficiency.

keep Regulations Prescribing Regions for the Purposes of Subsection 76(1) of the Canada Petroleum Resources Act SOR/87-641 · 2006
Summary

Defines 25 geographical regions (offshore and northern areas) for administering the Environmental Studies Research Fund under the Canada Petroleum Resources Act, with precise boundaries using coordinates and maritime limits.

Reason

Deleting these clearly defined regions would create administrative uncertainty and disputes over fund allocations, undermining the targeted support for environmental research related to petroleum resources. The precision makes the system predictable and legally defensible—something ad hoc boundaries cannot replicate.

keep Regulations Prescribing the Manner of Determining Interest for the Purpose of Subsections 64.1(1) and (2) of the Indian Act SOR/87-631 · 2006
Summary

These regulations govern the calculation of interest for individuals seeking reinstatement under the Indian Act, establishing how interest is computed on principal amounts, the rate applied, and the timing of interest accrual based on application dates and reinstatement status.

Reason

The regulation provides a clear, objective formula for interest calculation that ensures fairness and predictability for both individuals and the government. Without this regulation, interest calculations would be inconsistent and potentially arbitrary, creating uncertainty for people navigating the reinstatement process under the Indian Act. The quarterly calculation based on Bank of Canada rates is transparent and prevents disputes over interest amounts.

keep Regulations Respecting Zoning at Yorkton Airport SOR/87-605 · 2006
Summary

The Yorkton Airport Zoning Regulations restrict building heights and land use near Yorkton Airport to ensure safe aircraft operations. They establish imaginary surfaces (approach, outer, transitional) that obstructions cannot exceed, and prohibit waste disposal that could attract birds.

Reason

Removing these safety regulations would endanger air travel by allowing obstructions in flight paths and bird attractants near the airport. The externalities of a crash are catastrophic and far exceed any property rights infringement. Private coordination among numerous landowners is impracticable; uniform federal standards are essential for aviation safety and regional economic connectivity.