← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

keep Withdrawal of Certain Lands (North and South Baffin, Kitikmeot East and West and Keewatin, N.W.T.) from Disposal Order SI/92-139 · 2006
Summary

This regulation designates specific parcels of land in Nunavut as withdrawn from general Crown lands according to 1992 land claims agreements between the Tungavik Federation of Nunavut, Makivik Corporation, and Canada. It identifies Type 1 and Type 2 lands and maps that implement Inuit land rights settlements.

Reason

This regulation implements finalized Indigenous land claim settlements that provide legal certainty and property rights. Deleting it would breach binding contracts, create chaos in land titles, undermine Indigenous economic development, and threaten social stability—costs far exceeding any marginal benefit from returning these lands to unrestricted Crown disposition.

keep Tariff of Fees, Costs, Allowances and Expenses for Special Returning Officers and Other Persons Employed at or with Respect to a Referendum Under the Special Voting Rules SI/92-133 · 2006
Summary

This regulation establishes fee schedules for special returning officers, chief assistants, scrutineers, and clerical assistants working on referendums under the Special Voting Rules, including payments for services, special assignments, training sessions, and travel expenses.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off without clear, predictable compensation for referendum workers, as it would create administrative chaos, disputes over pay, and difficulty recruiting qualified personnel to administer democratic processes. This minimal administrative regulation ensures fair compensation and supports the integrity of referendums; ad-hoc negotiations would be inefficient and inconsistent.

delete Reservation to the Crown Waiver Order (Hay River, N.W.T.) SI/92-119 · 2006
Summary

This order grants tax remission to Indian residents receiving royalties or technical service fees from Canadian sources, reducing their effective tax rate from 30% to 20% on such income.

Reason

Creates unjustified tax preference that distorts cross-border investment decisions, reduces revenue, and violates equal treatment principle. The remission favors specific foreign nationality and income type, incentivizing artificial structuring and complicating the tax system without demonstrating a clear net benefit to Canadians that outweighs these distortions and compliance costs.

keep Withdrawal of Certain Lands (Fry Inlet on Contwoyto Lake, N.W.T.) from Disposal Order SI/92-111 · 2006
Summary

Designates two specific land parcels (01/76E and 02/76E) at Fry Inlet, Contwoyto Lake in the Northwest Territories as withdrawn from disposition per the 1991 Agreement between Tungavik Federation of Nunavut and Canada, implementing land claim obligations.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off if deleted: breaching this land claims agreement would trigger costly litigation, undermine indigenous relations, and create legal uncertainty that erodes property rights. The regulation's precise identification and mapping is essential to administer the agreement's terms in a clear, administrable way, preventing unauthorized development and disputes over land status.

delete Order Assigning to the Minister of the Environment, the Administration, Management and Control of Certain Public Lands SI/92-107 · 2006
Summary

This regulation establishes four land units (Last Mountain Lake, Saline Creek, West, and East) in Saskatchewan, totaling approximately 10,518 hectares, with detailed legal descriptions of parcels, exceptions for roadways and minerals, and specific land titles registrations.

Reason

This is a land registry document that serves no regulatory purpose - it merely describes existing property boundaries and exceptions. The free market and private property rights already govern these lands; no government intervention is needed to dictate land descriptions or mineral reservations.

delete Order Respecting the Remission of Certain Income Taxes Payable by Indians and of the Goods and Services Tax Payable by Indians or by Bands or Designated Corporations on Certain Indian Settlements SI/92-102 · 2006
Summary

Provides tax remission (income tax and GST) to Indigenous individuals, bands, and designated corporations in specific named settlements, treating these settlements as tax-exempt reserves under the Indian Act.

Reason

Discriminatory tax exemptions violate equal protection, create economic distortions and misallocation, and add bureaucratic complexity. Tax law should apply uniformly to all citizens without ethnic or geographic preferences.

keep Order Respecting the Remission of Duties, Including the Tax Imposed under Parts III, IV and IX of the Excise Tax Act, Paid or Payable on Goods, Real Property or Services for Use in Joint Canada — United States Government Projects SI/91-9 · 2006
Summary

Remission order for taxes and duties on goods, services, and real property used in joint Canada-US government projects or US government establishments in Canada

Reason

This remission order prevents double taxation and facilitates international cooperation on joint projects. Without it, US government operations in Canada would face Canadian taxes, creating diplomatic friction and administrative burden that would hinder bilateral cooperation on shared initiatives.

delete Order Respecting the Remission of Income Tax in Respect of Indians and The Seaway International Bridge Corporation, Ltd. SI/91-89 · 2006
Summary

A narrow tax remission order granting tax exemption to Indigenous workers employed by The Seaway International Bridge Corporation on Cornwall Island for income earned after 1983, tied to a specific Federal Court case (Mitchell v. St. Lawrence Seaway Authority), requiring waiver of appeals to receive the remission.

Reason

This is an obsolete, hyper-specific one-off remission order tied to a particular historical court dispute. It serves no ongoing policy function and merely grants a retroactive tax exemption to a closed class of individuals. Keeping it adds meaningless complexity to the statute books for zero economic benefit. The legal dispute it references has likely been resolved, and the targeted tax break created neither wealth nor liberty—it simply carved out an exception that should have been addressed through regular tax policy or treaty negotiation. Statutory clutter of this sort should be removed systematically.

delete Order Respecting the Remisson of Taxes Imposed under Division III of Part IX and any other Part of the Excise Tax Act, Paid or Payable on the Importation of Goods by Seasonal Residents SI/91-84 · 2006
Summary

Provides tax remission on import duties for non-resident seasonal residents bringing personal household effects to Canada. Applies to individuals who own or lease (≥3 years) a seasonal residence, excluding time-shares and mobile homes. Remission covers used goods previously owned by the resident, with a one-year holding period and one-time limit per person.

Reason

Imposes hidden costs: revenue loss from taxpayers subsidizing wealthy non-residents' second homes; administrative burden tracking imports; distorts housing markets by incentivizing seasonal occupancy that competes with full-time residents; violates tax neutrality through arbitrary distinctions (lease duration, time-share exclusion) that distort incentives and increase compliance complexity.

delete Order Respecting the Remission of a Portion of the Customs Duties Paid on a Continuous Casting System Imported Into Canada By Stelco Steel SI/91-71 · 2006
Summary

This order grants partial customs duty remission to Stelco Steel for a continuous casting system imported into Canada, requiring claims to be made within two years of the order's effective date.

Reason

This is a targeted subsidy that distorts market competition by giving preferential treatment to one company, creating unfair advantages and encouraging rent-seeking behavior rather than productive investment.

delete Order Respecting the Remission of Income Tax and Penalties Payable by Standard Trust Depositors SI/91-66 · 2006
Summary

This regulation provides tax and penalty remission to taxpayers who had deposits with Standard Trust Company or Standard Loan Company that were insured by the Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation. It covers income tax and remittance penalties accrued from April 18, 1991 to the date of insurance payout, with a $60,000 aggregate deposit limit.

Reason

This is a narrow, one-time tax relief measure for specific depositors in failed institutions. It creates arbitrary tax advantages for certain individuals based on timing and institution choice, distorting the tax system. Such targeted relief should be handled through general policy rather than creating permanent regulatory exceptions.

delete Order Approving the Exclusion by the Public Service Commission from the Operation of Section 10 and Subsection 21(1) of the Public Service Employment Act of Certain Persons and Positions SI/91-65 · 2006
Summary

This regulation excludes air traffic controllers from certain Public Service Employment Act requirements for specialized training and operational programs (Selection by Seniority Program and Transfer Down Program) from May 1, 1991 to December 31, 1996, including qualification requirements, appeal rights, and appointment procedures.

Reason

This regulation creates regulatory carve-outs that distort the merit-based hiring system, potentially allowing less qualified candidates to be appointed without proper appeal mechanisms, while the temporary nature (1991-1996) suggests it was a band-aid solution rather than addressing underlying structural issues in air traffic controller staffing and training.

keep Specifications Relating to the Design, Composition, Construction and Performance of Electronic Railway Track Scales for In-Motion Weighing and Relating to the Installation and Use Thereof SI/91-21 · 2006
Summary

Technical specifications for electronic railway track scales used for in-motion weighing in commercial transactions, setting requirements for design, accuracy (minimum 10 kg increment), safety features, installation standards, and operational protocols to ensure reliable weight measurements for trade purposes under the Weights and Measures Act.

Reason

Accurate and standardized weights and measures are foundational to market integrity. This regulation prevents fraud, ensures interoperability across jurisdictions, and provides a trusted basis for commercial transactions involving rail freight. Private certification would be less reliable for cross-border commerce and could lead to measurement inconsistencies that undermine market confidence. The compliance costs are modest relative to the billions in trade transactions relying on accurate weighing.

delete Withdrawal of Certain Lands (Mayo, Y.T.) from Disposal Order SI/91-155 · 2006
Summary

Regulation designates Yukon parcels as 'COMMUNITY LANDS', 'RURAL LANDS', and 'AREAS FOR SITE SPECIFIC SELECTION' based on government maps, while excepting lands under existing lease or sale agreements. This classification likely triggers restrictive land-use rules that limit voluntary exchange and development.

Reason

It creates government-controlled land-use categories that restrict property rights, suppress supply (especially housing), increase transaction costs, and distort market allocation. These barriers reduce wealth creation, raise living costs, and impede Yukon's economic competitiveness and individual liberty.

delete Order Respecting the Remission of Income Taxes Payable in Respect of Quebec Family Allowances for 1990 and 1991 SI/91-153 · 2006
Summary

This 1991 Order provides tax remission to Quebec residents who received provincial family allowances in 1990-1991, adjusting federal tax calculations to exclude these allowances from taxable income and refunding overpaid taxes.

Reason

This regulation is obsolete (applies only to 1990-1991) and represents a special-interest tax break that violates equal treatment principles. It created administrative complexity and distorted tax incentives by providing unique treatment to Quebec family allowance recipients, setting a precedent for province-specific federal tax measures that fragment the national tax system. Even if still active, tax remissions for government transfers interfere with market signals and create inequities between provinces.