← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete Order Amending the Sechelt Indian Band Constitution SOR/2019-307 · 2019
Summary

Regulation amends Sechelt Indian Band constitution to expand voting rights, allow non-resident members to run for office, clarify election procedures, and mandate a separate election law.

Reason

Federal regulation of a specific First Nations' constitution violates self-determination principles, imposes unnecessary oversight, and creates precedent for micromanagement of indigenous governance; the costs include bureaucratic burden, reduced local autonomy, and wasted federal resources.

keep Transitional Regulations for the Purpose of the National Energy Board Cost Recovery Regulations SOR/2019-300 · 2019
Summary

This is a transitional regulation ensuring the Canadian Energy Regulator (CER) continues applying the National Energy Board Cost Recovery Regulations after the CER's establishment. It mandates the CER to complete any cost recovery calculations started by the NEB and begin new ones under the CER's mandate, with modifications to rename references from NEB to CER and adjust cost attribution periods accordingly.

Reason

Deleting this transitional regulation would create a legal gap in the authority to collect cost recovery fees during the administrative transition from NEB to CER, causing uncertainty that could disrupt the regulator's funding and impair its ability to oversee Canada's energy infrastructure. It achieves continuity in a simple, direct way that would be difficult to replicate without explicit legislative bridging.

keep Critical Habitat of the Coastrange Sculpin (Cottus aleuticus) Cultus Population Order SOR/2019-3 · 2019
Summary

Designates critical habitat for the Cultus population of Coastrange Sculpin under the Species at Risk Act, making it subject to legal protections and restrictions on harmful activities.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off if this regulation was deleted because it protects a unique freshwater fish population that exists nowhere else. The Cultus Sculpin is a distinct population with limited habitat in BC's Cultus Lake system, and without legal protection, development, pollution, and habitat degradation would likely cause its extinction. The regulation achieves its conservation goal through established legal mechanisms that are difficult to replicate through voluntary measures alone.

delete Fabricated Industrial Steel Components Anti-dumping and Countervailing Duty Remission Order SOR/2019-297 · 2019
Summary

Remission of anti-dumping and countervailing duties on fabricated industrial steel components used in two LNG projects in British Columbia, conditional on filing within 2 years and providing eligibility evidence.

Reason

This selective tariff remission creates market distortions by picking winners among energy projects, undermining the principle of uniform trade policy. It sets a dangerous precedent for regulatory favoritism while the broader anti-dumping framework remains problematic.

keep CPTPP Remission Order SOR/2019-293 · 2019
Summary

Grants remission of customs duties on imported tires (tariff 4011.90.90) claimed under CPTPP treatment for imports between Dec 30, 2018 and registration, requiring claims within two years.

Reason

Deleting would deny importers duty refunds, increasing costs and breaching CPTPP obligations, harming trade and consumers. The order efficiently implements retroactive duty relief, a mechanism hard to replicate without legislative delay.

keep Exemption Order for Certain Licences, Authorizations and Documents (Rainbow Trout (Athabasca River Populations)) SOR/2019-289 · 2019
Summary

This regulation provides a one-year exemption from Section 32 of the Species at Risk Act for sportfishing activities targeting Rainbow Trout in the Athabasca River populations, allowing continued fishing under existing Alberta and National Parks regulations.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off if this exemption was deleted because it would immediately prohibit recreational fishing for Rainbow Trout, eliminating a popular outdoor activity and economic driver for local communities without providing any conservation benefit during the critical transition period when alternative management approaches could be developed.

keep Exemption Order for Certain Licences, Authorizations and Documents (Bull Trout (Saskatchewan-Nelson Rivers Populations)) SOR/2019-288 · 2019
Summary

Provides a one-year exemption from Section 32 of the Species at Risk Act for specified fishing licences and regulations relating to Bull Trout (Saskatchewan-Nelson Rivers populations), allowing continued sportfishing and related activities despite the species being listed at risk.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off without this exemption as it prevents immediate, heavy-handed restrictions that would disrupt legal fishing activities, harm businesses and communities dependent on fisheries, and needlessly curtail economic liberty. The exemption achieves its goal of reducing regulatory burden in a targeted, time-limited manner that would be difficult to replicate through broader legislative changes, providing an essential balance between conservation and prosperity.

delete Authorizations Concerning Fish and Fish Habitat Protection Regulations SOR/2019-286 · 2019
Summary

Regulation establishes application process for Fisheries Act authorizations to carry out works that may harm fish or fish habitat, requiring detailed environmental assessments, offsetting plans, financial guarantees, and setting procedural timelines for review, amendment, suspension, and cancellation by the Minister.

Reason

The regulation imposes substantial regulatory burden through exhaustive documentation requirements, financial guarantees, and discretionary ministerial powers that delay projects, increase costs, and restrict economic development. These barriers exacerbate Canada's housing supply crisis, reduce competitiveness, force capital into compliance rather than productive use, and violate principles of liberty and private property while producing unintended harms that outweigh any environmental benefits.

delete Physical Activities Regulations SOR/2019-285 · 2019
Summary

This regulation designates which physical activities constitute 'designated projects' requiring federal impact assessment under the Impact Assessment Act. It lists hundreds of project types and capacity thresholds across sectors like mining, energy, infrastructure, transportation, and defense, primarily for projects on federal lands, national parks, marine conservation areas, or those with potential cross-jurisdictional impacts.

Reason

This regulation imposes a massive pre-approval burden that stifles development, increases costs, and creates uncertainty. It centralizes decision-making, overrides local jurisdiction, and is exploited by special interests to delay or block needed infrastructure, housing, and energy projects. The unseen costs include reduced investment, forgone economic opportunities, higher consumer prices, and Canada's competitive disadvantage relative to the US. Environmental protection can be achieved more efficiently through property rights, tort law, and market-based mechanisms without the heavy-handed prior restraint regime.

delete Information and Management of Time Limits Regulations SOR/2019-283 · 2019
Summary

The Impact Assessment Act regulations establish a comprehensive federal framework for environmental and social impact assessments of designated projects, including detailed information requirements, time limits, suspension provisions, and consultation processes with Indigenous peoples and the public.

Reason

This regulatory framework creates massive bureaucratic delays and costs that deter investment, suppress economic growth, and reduce Canada's competitiveness. The extensive consultation requirements and rigid timelines increase housing, energy, and infrastructure costs while driving talent and capital to more market-friendly jurisdictions. The unintended consequences include fewer projects being built, reduced supply of essential goods and services, and Canada falling behind in global competitiveness.

keep CIFTA Tariff Preference Regulations SOR/2019-278 · 2019
Summary

Regulation implements tariff preferences for originating goods from Israel and other CIFTA beneficiaries, setting conditions for preferential treatment including rules about transshipment through non-Party countries (EU, EFTA, Jordan, Mexico, USA). It also repeals previous CIFTA regulations and includes coming-into-force provisions.

Reason

Deleting this regulation would raise tariffs on qualifying Israeli goods, increasing costs for Canadian consumers and businesses. While not equivalent to unilateral free trade, this regulation administers a bilateral agreement that demonstrably reduces trade barriers relative to MFN tariffs. The rules prevent abuse through transshipment while maintaining preferential access.

delete CIFTA Rules of Origin Regulations SOR/2019-276 · 2019
Summary

Repeals CIFTA Rules of Origin Regulations and incorporates specific provisions of the Canada-Israel Free Trade Agreement into Canadian law, updating trade rules between Canada and Israel.

Reason

Free trade agreements create regulatory complexity that benefits special interests while raising costs for consumers through compliance burdens and reduced competition. This regulation perpetuates managed trade rather than true free trade, and its repeal would signal commitment to genuine market liberalization.

delete Critical Habitat of the Salish Sucker (Catostomus catostomus ssp.) Order SOR/2019-274 · 2019
Summary

Designates critical habitat for the Salish Sucker under the Species at Risk Act, restricting land use and development in those areas to protect the species.

Reason

Infringes property rights and imposes land-use restrictions that reduce housing supply and economic opportunity with uncertain ecological benefits. Voluntary conservation, habitat banking, or private reserves could achieve species protection without regulatory coercion, and the opportunity cost of foregone development outweighs the diffuse, long-term benefits.

delete Output-Based Pricing System Regulations SOR/2019-266 · 2019
Summary

Regulation implementing an output-based pricing system for industrial GHG emissions under the Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act. Defines facility scope, reporting/verification requirements, emissions limits via output-based standards, and compensation mechanisms for excess emissions.

Reason

The complex administrative regime imposes high compliance costs, distorts market incentives, and creates competitive disadvantages for Canadian industry. Unseen costs include capital diverted from productive investment, increased regulatory burden contributing to brain drain, and barriers to entry that protect incumbents—undermining prosperity, liberty, and interprovincial competitiveness.

delete Large Diameter Line Pipe Anti-dumping Duty Remission Order SOR/2019-261 · 2019
Summary

This regulation provides targeted anti-dumping duty remissions for specific companies importing large diameter line pipe, with conditions including application deadlines, documentation requirements, and project-specific restrictions for Trans Mountain Pipeline L.P.

Reason

This selective duty remission creates market distortions by favoring certain companies and projects over others, undermining competitive neutrality and creating regulatory capture where politically connected firms receive preferential treatment while others face full duties.