← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete Joint Notice Specifying the Prohibition Period For Certain Activities on Georges Bank SOR/2016-70 · 2016
Summary

Prohibits offshore petroleum exploration, drilling, production, conservation, processing, and transportation in a specific offshore area (Schedule IV of the Canada-Nova Scotia Offshore Petroleum Resources Accord Implementation Act) from April 15, 2016 to December 31, 2022.

Reason

Expired December 31, 2022. The prohibition would have restricted energy supply and investment, imposing economic costs without demonstrated public benefit.

keep Personal Health Information Custodians in Nova Scotia Exemption Order SOR/2016-62 · 2016
Summary

This Order exempts Nova Scotia health information custodians governed by the Personal Health Information Act from Part 1 of the federal Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA) for personal health information collected, used, or disclosed in Nova Scotia, thereby avoiding duplicative privacy regulation by allowing the provincial framework to govern in that province.

Reason

Deleting this Order would impose duplicative compliance burdens on Nova Scotia health custodians, forcing adherence to both provincial and federal privacy regimes, increasing costs and administrative complexity without added benefit. The exemption respects provincial jurisdiction, prevents federal overreach, and reduces regulatory burden—core principles of limited government. The desired outcome (avoiding double regulation) would be hard to achieve otherwise without creating gaps or conflicts between the two regimes.

delete Prince Edward Island Potato Marketing Levies Order SOR/2016-49 · 2016
Summary

This regulation imposes mandatory levies on potato marketing activities in Prince Edward Island: processors pay $0.09 per 100 lb on potatoes shipped outside PEI for processing, while dealers and exporters pay $0.13 per 100 lb on interprovincial and export sales. The levies fund a Commodity Board and require monthly remittance with detailed transaction reports.

Reason

The levy acts as an internal trade barrier that increases costs for PEI potato businesses, distorts market decisions, and creates administrative burdens. These costs are ultimately passed to consumers and reduce competitiveness relative to other provinces. Mandatory participation in the Commodity Board eliminates consumer sovereignty and forces businesses to fund activities that should be provided voluntarily by the private sector. The regulation exemplifies the harmful effects of interventionism: it suppresses supply, raises prices, and violates the principle of free trade within Canada's internal market.

delete Ste. Anne’s Hospital Divestiture Regulations SOR/2016-48 · 2016
Summary

Regulation provides pension continuity rules for federal public service employees who transfer to employment at a specific Quebec health and social services center (CIUSSS de l'Ouest-de-l'Île-de-Montréal) under a 2015 agreement. It ensures they retain pension benefits as if still in public service, defines pensionable service calculations, and provides one-year options for return of contributions or pension options.

Reason

This is a narrow, government-created special arrangement for one specific Quebec institution that picks winners and maintains public sector pension privileges that distort labor mobility. It creates a unique regulatory carve-out rather than allowing standard pension portability rules to apply equally to all workers. The regulation preserves government-backed benefits for transfers to a single provincial entity, creating unequal treatment and administrative complexity.

delete Potable Water on Board Trains, Vessels, Aircraft and Buses Regulations SOR/2016-43 · 2016
Summary

Regulation mandates potable water standards, periodic E. coli testing, disinfection protocols, and record-keeping for commercial passenger transportation (aircraft, vessels, buses, trains) with 25+ passengers.

Reason

Creates unnecessary compliance costs and barriers to entry. Market incentives (reputation, liability) and private ordering (insurance standards, contractual obligations) adequately ensure water safety without coercive one-size-fits-all mandates. The regulation's arbitrary testing frequencies and record-keeping requirements impose deadweight losses that reduce competitiveness and consumer welfare.

delete Prevention and Control of Fires on Line Works Regulations SOR/2016-317 · 2016
Summary

Railway fire safety regulations requiring companies to have fire preparedness and hazard reduction plans, notify fire services for high-risk work, maintain suppression equipment, and keep records of fire incidents and safety procedures.

Reason

Creates costly compliance burden that raises rail transport prices without clear evidence of preventing fires better than market incentives. Railway companies already have strong financial incentives to prevent fires that could damage their own property and equipment.

delete Energy Efficiency Regulations, 2016 SOR/2016-311 · 2016
Summary

This regulation mandates energy efficiency standards and labeling requirements for a wide range of energy-using products including household appliances (clothes dryers, washers, dishwashers, refrigerators), lighting (lamps, ballasts), motors, transformers, and commercial equipment. It requires products to meet prescribed efficiency standards, carry verification marks, and dealers to report product information to the Minister before interprovincial shipment or importation.

Reason

This regulation imposes significant compliance costs on businesses, restricts consumer choice, and distorts market signals. Energy efficiency is a feature consumers value and would demand through normal market mechanisms. Mandatory standards create barriers to entry, reduce competition, increase prices, and stifle innovation by dictating technical specifications. The reporting and labeling bureaucracy wastes resources that could be deployed productively. Any environmental benefits are outweighed by the unseen costs: higher prices for consumers (especially low-income households), reduced supply ofproducts, delayed market adoption of better technologies, and the impossibility of central planners determining optimal efficiency levels for diverse products and consumer preferences.

delete Marine Liability and Information Return Regulations SOR/2016-307 · 2016
Summary

Regulation establishes reporting requirements for receivers and exporters of oil and hazardous substances transported by sea, requiring annual information returns detailing quantities, types, and contact information for entities handling more than 150,000 metric tons of oil or 17,000 metric tons of other specified substances. Also imposes $98 fees for Civil Liability Convention and Bunkers Convention certificates.

Reason

The information return requirements impose significant compliance costs on maritime businesses for data that could be obtained through existing port, customs, or vessel tracking systems. This administrative burden reduces competitiveness, increases costs, and creates barriers to entry without demonstrably improving pollution response beyond what could be achieved more efficiently. The regulation represents unnecessary paperwork that contradicts principles of economic liberty and limited government.

delete Assessment of Financial Institutions Regulations, 2017 SOR/2016-297 · 2016
Summary

This regulation establishes the fee assessment system for the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI), requiring financial institutions (banks, insurance companies, trust companies, credit associations) to pay annual assessments to fund OSFI's regulatory operations. It sets minimum fees ($2,000-$30,000 based on institution type), calculates additional amounts based on capital proportions and administrative costs, and imposes surcharges on institutions with poor regulatory 'stage ratings'.

Reason

This is a pure regulatory tax that increases costs for financial institutions, which get passed to consumers through higher fees and lower returns. The minimum assessments alone create a barrier to entry that disproportionately harms smaller institutions and credit unions. The funding model creates perverse incentives: regulators are financially dependent on those they regulate, softens enforcement discipline, and justifies expanding regulatory scope to generate more revenue. The complexity breeds compliance costs while delivering no consumer benefit - the same oversight could be funded through general revenues with far less distortion to financial markets. Housing and business formation indirectly suffer as mortgage lenders and community banks face higher fixed costs.

keep Canadian Payments Association By-law No. 2 — Finance SOR/2016-283 · 2016
Summary

This is a by-law of the Canadian Payments Association that establishes how fees and dues are calculated and collected from members and participants in payment systems. It sets formulas for common services dues (based on equal-benefit costs divided among members), transaction fees (based on system operating costs allocated by transaction volume/value), and service fees (cost-based). It specifies timelines, adjustment mechanisms, interest on overdue amounts, and provisions for reserves and surpluses.

Reason

This by-law ensures transparent, cost-based allocation of expenses for critical national payment infrastructure. Deleting it would create fee uncertainty, undermine system stability, and disrupt financial networks Canadians rely on. The mechanism is neither distortionary nor burdensome—it simply recovers actual costs proportionally from voluntary participants in cooperative systems.

keep Critical Habitat of the Roseate Tern (Sterna dougallii) Order SOR/2016-281 · 2016
Summary

Protects critical habitat of Roseate Tern and associated tern colonies in Nova Scotia by establishing 200m coastal buffer zones around nesting areas, excluding Sable Island National Park Reserve.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off if this regulation was deleted because it prevents irreversible loss of endangered species habitat. The 200m buffer zones are a targeted, minimally invasive mechanism that protects breeding grounds without significantly restricting human activity, achieving conservation goals that would be difficult to accomplish through voluntary measures given the economic pressures on coastal development.

keep Anguniaqvia niqiqyuam Marine Protected Areas Regulations SOR/2016-280 · 2016
Summary

Designates Anguniaqvia niqiqyuam Marine Protected Areas in the Beaufort Sea to conserve marine ecosystems, prohibiting most activities that disturb marine life while allowing specific exceptions for Indigenous fishing rights, subsistence use, navigation, emergency response, and approved research/tourism activities with strict oversight and reporting requirements.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off if these protected areas were deleted because they preserve critical Arctic marine habitats that support biodiversity, Indigenous subsistence rights, and sustainable fisheries. The regulations balance conservation with practical exceptions for navigation, emergency response, and scientifically managed activities, achieving ecosystem protection in a way that would be difficult to replicate through voluntary measures alone given the Arctic's unique environmental sensitivity and international maritime interests.

delete Port of Prince Rupert Liquefied Natural Gas Facilities Regulations SOR/2016-260 · 2016
Summary

Federal regulation that incorporates British Columbia's environmental, drinking water, and oil/gas laws to apply specifically to liquefied natural gas activities at the Port of Prince Rupert, with numerous adaptations favoring federal and port authority interests.

Reason

Creates a complex, bespoke regulatory overlay that increases compliance costs, deters investment, and entrenches command-and-control environmental regulation. The unseen costs include delayed projects, reduced competitiveness, and regulatory capture. Environmental protection can be achieved through property rights and tort law more efficiently without this bureaucratic barrier to LNG supply and innovation.

delete Canada Oil and Gas Operations Financial Requirements Regulations SOR/2016-26 · 2016
Summary

This regulation establishes financial requirements for oil and gas operations in Canada, including proof of financial resources, pooled funds for liability coverage, and administrative procedures for the National Energy Board to assess financial capacity and recommend reduced liability amounts.

Reason

Creates artificial barriers to entry in the energy sector, reduces competition, increases costs for consumers, and establishes regulatory capture through complex financial requirements that favor large established companies over smaller innovators.

delete Canada Oil and Gas Operations Administrative Monetary Penalties Regulations SOR/2016-25 · 2016
Summary

Regulation creates an administrative penalties framework for violations under the Canada Oil and Gas Operations Act. It classifies violations as Type A or Type B, establishes a 'gravity value' system to determine penalty amounts, and outlines service procedures for violation notices.

Reason

Administrative penalties bypass full judicial process with weaker due process protections. The subjective 'gravity value' system invites arbitrary enforcement, increasing regulatory uncertainty. This 'red tape' makes Canada less competitive and burdens businesses. Legitimate enforcement should occur through regular courts.