← Back to overview

Browse regulations

Search, filter, and sort all reviewed regulations.

delete Nunavut Borrowing Limits Regulations SOR/2013-40 · 2013
Summary

Defines 'borrowing' for the government reporting entity of Nunavut under the Nunavut Act, specifying which financial obligations (loans, capital leases, sale-leasebacks, loan guarantees) count as borrowing, how to value them, and excludes intra-government transactions and certain CMHC housing loans.

Reason

This technical accounting regulation adds unnecessary bureaucratic complexity and compliance costs while enabling opaque debt reporting through threshold-based exclusions and mutable accounting standards. The CMHC loan exemption is a special-interest carve-out that could mask true fiscal obligations. Simple, transparent financial reporting—without regulatory minutiae—would achieve greater accountability and reduce the administrative burden.

delete Northwest Territories Borrowing Limits Regulations SOR/2013-39 · 2013
Summary

Detailed safety and construction regulations for large commercial fishing vessels (over 24.4m or 150 tons), prescribing specific standards for stability testing, bilge pumps, fuel tanks, electrical systems, materials, and equipment. Mandates compliance with technical specifications and approval requirements.

Reason

Prescriptive technical standards impose heavy compliance costs, restrict innovation, and limit supply in Canada's fishing industry. Safety is better achieved through liability law, insurance markets, and industry-led standards. The regulation criminalizes voluntary arrangements between informed parties, creates barriers to entry, and reduces economic competitiveness. The externalities of fishing accidents (environmental damage, rescue costs) could be addressed more efficiently through targeted liability and bonding requirements rather than blanket construction mandates.

keep Yukon Borrowing Limits Regulations SOR/2013-38 · 2013
Summary

Regulation defines 'borrowing' for Yukon government under the Yukon Act, including loans, capital leases, sale-leasebacks, and loan guarantees, with exclusions for intra-government transactions and valuation methods per CPA Canada standards.

Reason

Deletion would obscure Yukon government borrowing, including loan guarantees, reducing accountability and potentially enabling excessive debt that burdens taxpayers. The regulation provides legally binding clarity, ensuring consistent application of borrowing limits, which non-binding guidelines may not achieve.

keep Exemption Order for Certain Licences, Authorizations and Documents (Westslope Cutthroat Trout (Alberta Population)) SOR/2013-35 · 2013
Summary

This Order temporarily exempts specific Alberta fishing licences and authorizations from the Species at Risk Act's prohibitions for the Westslope Cutthroat Trout (Alberta population) for one year, allowing continued sportfishing and related activities.

Reason

Deleting this exemption would reimpose Species at Risk Act restrictions on Alberta's fisheries, imposing regulatory burdens that stifle local economies, infringe property rights, and create perverse incentives without demonstrating effective conservation; the exemption allows market-based management and protects livelihoods.

delete Ontario Review of Parole Ineligibility Rules (Rule 50) SOR/2013-249 · 2013
Summary

Ontario court rule governing applications under Criminal Code s. 745.6 for reduction of parole ineligibility periods for murder convictions. It mandates detailed forms, multiple service requirements, judicial screening, case management hearings, mandatory correctional reports, and specific jury procedures.

Reason

The rule imposes needlessly complex procedural burdens that increase taxpayer costs, delay justice, and deter valid applications from incarcerated individuals. Its elaborate requirements—multiple forms, service on five parties, pre-jury screening, mandatory correctional reports, extensive case management—create bureaucratic overhead while adding little to substantive fairness. The same statutory right could be administered with far simpler procedures, exemplifying Hayek's critique of constructivist legal rationalism that ignores unseen costs of regulation.

keep Air Canada Pension Plan Funding Regulations, 2014 SOR/2013-244 · 2013
Summary

This regulation governs pension funding for Air Canada's defined benefit plans, establishing special solvency funding requirements, payment formulas, and termination provisions to ensure pension plan stability.

Reason

Canadians would be worse off if deleted because it protects pension beneficiaries from Air Canada's insolvency risk, ensuring retirement security for thousands of workers who have earned defined benefits through years of service.

delete Ontario Grain Order SOR/2013-243 · 2013
Summary

This regulation authorizes the Grain Farmers of Ontario and Ontario Farm Products Marketing Commission to regulate grain marketing in interprovincial and export trade, including fixing levies and charges on producers, and using those funds for various purposes including reserves and equalization payments.

Reason

This creates a cartel-like system that restricts free market competition, artificially inflates prices through mandated levies, and redistributes money from successful producers to others, reducing overall agricultural productivity and innovation while increasing consumer costs.

delete Saskatchewan Winter Cereals Order SOR/2013-242 · 2013
Summary

Regulation establishes a Saskatchewan commodity board with authority to regulate interprovincial and export trade of winter cereals, collect mandatory levies from producers, and redistribute revenue for reserves and equalization among producers.

Reason

This forced marketing board system violates economic liberty by controlling trade, imposing compulsory levies, and redistributing income. It distorts market signals, raises costs, restricts supply, and undermines property rights. Canadians would be better off with free market allocation through voluntary exchange.

delete Saskatchewan Canaryseed Order SOR/2013-241 · 2013
Summary

Establishes a marketing board system for canaryseed that authorizes provincial boards to regulate interprovincial and export trade, impose mandatory levies on producers, and control marketing activities including price equalization and reserve creation.

Reason

This regulation creates interprovincial trade barriers contrary to free market principles, forces producers to fund government-mandated marketing schemes through compulsory levies, and artificially distorts market signals through price controls and supply management. The unseen costs include reduced competition, suppressed innovation, barriers to entry for new producers, and misallocation of resources that would otherwise respond to genuine market demand. Any perceived benefits of orderly marketing could be achieved voluntarily through producer cooperatives without coercion.

delete Saskatchewan Forage Seed Order SOR/2013-240 · 2013
Summary

This regulation establishes the Saskatchewan Forage Seed Development Commission and authorizes it to regulate interprovincial and export marketing of forage seed, collect mandatory levies from producers, and redistribute revenues through equalization payments among producers.

Reason

This regulation creates a state-sanctioned marketing monopoly that restricts free trade, forces producers to fund equalization schemes, and distorts price signals. The mandatory levies coercively extract resources from producers to fund regulatory activities that would be better served by voluntary market institutions. The 'equalization' mechanism artificially redistributes income rather than letting competition allocate resources efficiently, leading to misaligned production incentives, reduced overall supply, and higher costs for consumers. The board's power over interprovincial trade violates the principle of free movement of goods between provinces, creating barriers that fragment the national market and reduce economies of scale.

delete Heavy-duty Vehicle and Engine Greenhouse Gas Emission Regulations SOR/2013-24 · 2013
Summary

This regulation mandates greenhouse gas emission standards for heavy-duty vehicles, engines, and trailers in Canada, closely harmonized with US EPA standards. It defines technical terms, vehicle classifications, testing procedures, and compliance mechanisms including averaging sets and CO2 family certification levels. Companies must meet specified emission limits through engineering design and can use credit systems to average emissions across fleets.

Reason

The regulation imposes centralized mandates that increase manufacturing costs, reduce consumer choice, and stifle market-driven innovation. The complex compliance framework creates barriers to entry, distorts resource allocation, and embodies the knowledge problem—bureaucrats cannot optimally determine emission standards for diverse vehicle applications. Unseen costs include reduced competition, higher prices, and administrative burden diverting resources from productive enterprise. Cleaner vehicles will emerge through consumer demand and tort law addressing actual harm, not through government prescription of technical specifications.

delete Saskatchewan Mustard Order SOR/2013-239 · 2013
Summary

This regulation authorizes the Saskatchewan Mustard Development Commission and Agri-Food Council to control interprovincial and export trade of mustard, including setting levies, charges, and marketing controls within Saskatchewan.

Reason

This regulation restricts free trade by giving government bodies control over mustard marketing and pricing, creating barriers to interprovincial commerce and export opportunities. It distorts market signals, reduces supply, and increases costs for producers and consumers through mandatory levies and centralized control.

delete New Brunswick Blueberry Order SOR/2013-238 · 2013
Summary

This Order authorizes the New Brunswick blueberry marketing boards to regulate interprovincial and export trade, collecting compulsory levies from producers and redistributing revenues among them to equalize returns.

Reason

This regulation creates a constitutional interprovincial trade barrier by granting marketing boards control over blueberry commerce, violating the principle of free internal trade that should exist between provinces. The compulsory levies and forced revenue equalization distort market signals, protect inefficient producers, restrict supply, and raise costs for Canadian consumers. Such supply-control mechanisms are the antithesis of liberty and property rights—they substitute central planning for voluntary exchange and inevitably create deadweight loss, reduced competition, and artificial scarcity in the marketplace.

delete Allocation Method Order (2014) — Softwood Lumber Products SOR/2013-236 · 2013
Summary

This regulation establishes the method for allocating softwood lumber export quotas from Ontario, Quebec, Manitoba, and Saskatchewan to the United States in 2014, based on historical export volumes and production data, with specific formulas for different producer categories and a minimum allocation for remanufacturers.

Reason

This regulation creates artificial scarcity through export quotas that distort market prices, prevent efficient resource allocation, and impose bureaucratic compliance costs. By restricting trade between Canadian provinces and the US, it raises lumber prices for Canadian consumers and construction, while protecting incumbent producers from competition. The complex allocation formulas and administrative burden harm economic freedom without providing clear public benefits - free trade would better serve Canadian prosperity.

delete Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations SOR/2013-221 · 2013
Summary

Regulation implements Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL), requiring consent for commercial electronic messages with numerous exemptions for family/personal relationships, organizational communications, solicitations, legal obligations, foreign-state compliance, charities, and political fundraising. It also governs consent transfer, membership definitions, and network security programs.

Reason

Imposes heavy compliance costs on legitimate businesses, chills commercial speech, and substitutes bureaucratic mandates for market-based solutions. The complex exemptions create legal uncertainty and enforcement risks, disproportionately burden small enterprises, and stifle innovation in digital marketing. Unseen costs include reduced information flow to consumers, barriers to entry, and regulatory capture opportunities. Property rights and tort law could address harms without preempting voluntary communication.